Arm wrestling


Men Save More – Women Save Better

This will not surprise you: men have more money saved for retirement than women.

Savings rates chartMen averaged $123,262 in their defined contribution plans, compared with $79,572 for women, according to a new report by Vanguard based on its 2014 recordkeeping data.

But these figures hide a larger truth: women are actually better at saving for retirement.

“Overall, women are better at this but men earn more money so they have higher wealth accumulation,” says Vanguard researcher Jean Young, author of the new report, “Women versus Men in DC Plans.”

Young’s research found that women are 14 percent more likely to enroll in a voluntary workplace retirement savings plan. Women save 7 percent of pay, compared with 6.8 percent for men, controlling for wages, job tenure, and plan design. They also save at higher rates than men at every income level.

Her findings also refute the old wive’s tale that women don’t like risky investing.

Both men and women hold roughly three-fourths of their retirement accounts in the stock market. A possibly related finding is that women more often turn asset allocation decisions over to professionals or professionally managed Target Date Funds.

Since women save less in total, what does the Vanguard report say about how secure women are in retirement? What matters to a retiree is whether she has sufficient income to maintain the standard of living she had when she was working, and that standard is usually pegged to how much she earned – and women earn about 77 cents to a male coworker’s dollar.

While women “might not end up with as much wealth as a man,” Young concludes, their lifestyle adjustment in retirement also “is probably not going to be as harsh, because we’re better at this.”

To stay current on our Squared Away blog, we invite you to join our free email list. You’ll receive just one email each week – with links to the two new posts for that week – when you sign up here.   

3 Responses to Men Save More – Women Save Better

  1. Michael Waggoner says:

    The headline may be misleading. Both chart and text show that at any income level, women on average save more. Men on average only save more because on average they have higher incomes, but they save a smaller percent of those incomes. Thus it appears that women are better savers, because they save a higher percentage of their incomes, and they save more wisely.

  2. tj says:

    What about the fact that women live much longer than men? Regardless of amount saved there is a bigger risk that a woman could run out of money due to inflation, etc. if she lives too long.

  3. Brian says:

    At the end of the day, all that matters is whose stack is larger.

    So, no matter who saves more, a higher percentage, or wiser,…to use the old adage, “He who dies with the most toys wins.”